Fat Brain Toys wins hands-down for babies and young toddlers (6-24 months). Their original designs like Dimpl, SpinAgain, and InnyBin are genuinely best-in-class for sensory and fine motor development. Learning Resources pulls ahead for preschoolers and kindergartners (3-6 years) where their math, science, and literacy tools are classroom-proven. Buy Fat Brain for the wow factor and early development; buy Learning Resources for structured academic readiness.
Your 14-month-old needs more stimulation than another set of stacking cups. You want something genuinely clever — toys that make you think 'why didn't this exist before?' That search leads to two very different companies: Fat Brain Toys, the innovative disruptor designing toys nobody else makes, and Learning Resources, the classroom-tested veteran that teachers have trusted for decades.
Fat Brain creates original designs like the Dimpl (genius silicone bubble popper) and SpinAgain (mesmerizing stacking spinner). Learning Resources perfects educational staples like counting bears, pattern blocks, and science kits. Both deliver genuine educational value, but they scratch very different itches.
By the Numbers
How these two compare on the metrics that matter most.
Top 5 Picks from Each Side
Our highest-rated products from both categories.
Fat Brain Toys
Learning Resources
Strengths & Weaknesses
What each side does well and where it falls short.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Fat Brain Toys' original designs worth the premium?
For their signature products (Dimpl, SpinAgain, Tobbles, InnyBin), absolutely yes. These are genuinely innovative toys that provide unique developmental experiences. Their curated third-party selection is also well-vetted. For generic items, you can find equivalent quality elsewhere for less.
Is Learning Resources good for Montessori homes?
Many Learning Resources products work well in Montessori settings — counting bears, pattern blocks, sorting sets, and balance scales are practically Montessori materials. Some products are more teacher-directed, so choose items that allow independent exploration.
Which brand is better for toddlers (1-3 years)?
Fat Brain Toys has some of the best toddler toys on the market. SpinAgain, Dimpl, and Tobbles were specifically designed for toddler hands and attention spans. Learning Resources is stronger starting around age 3 when academic readiness becomes relevant.
Can I find both brands on Amazon?
Yes, both sell extensively on Amazon with Prime shipping. Fat Brain Toys also has their own website with exclusive products and bundles. Learning Resources is widely available at Target, Walmart, and educational supply stores.
Which brand has better customer ratings?
Both maintain excellent ratings. Fat Brain's signature products consistently earn 4.7-4.9 stars. Learning Resources' top sellers hover around 4.5-4.8. The slight edge goes to Fat Brain for their original designs, which tend to generate enthusiastic reviews.
Are these brands worth buying over Melissa & Doug?
They serve different needs. Melissa & Doug covers basics (puzzles, pretend play, practical life). Fat Brain offers innovative alternatives you won't find elsewhere. Learning Resources fills the academic/STEM gap. A well-rounded playroom might include all three.
Which is better for a child who gets bored easily?
Fat Brain Toys. Their designs are specifically engineered for engagement and novelty. The SpinAgain's spinning action and Dimpl's satisfying pop keep children coming back. Learning Resources products, while educational, tend toward more traditional play patterns.
Do either brand make good gifts for kids I don't know well?
Fat Brain Toys is the better blind gift — their original designs are universally appealing and most parents haven't seen them before. Learning Resources is a safer gift if you know the child's age and interests, especially for school-readiness gifts.
Still Not Sure?
Use our free tools to find the perfect toy for your child's age and interests.